Italy’s 4-1 defeat by Belgium has prompted a mixed reaction from the country’s newspapers after the Azzurri fell from first to third in their Nations League group and were eliminated from the competition.
Italy had moved to the top of the table with an impressive 3-1 home victory over France on Thursday. But their position changed dramatically on Sunday, when Belgium won heavily and France beat Turkey 2-1.
The Azzurri made the ideal start as the in-form Pio Esposito scored his 10th goal for the national team. However, their advantage disappeared as Maxim De Cuyper, Nathan Ngoy and Jeremy Doku scored three times in an 11-minute spell before half-time.
Milan’s Diego Moreira added Belgium’s fourth late on. Esposito then missed a penalty that would have made the score 4-2.
The Italian press offered differing assessments on Monday, with several newspapers critical of the nature of the defeat but keen to emphasise the progress made during the campaign.
La Gazzetta dello Sport focused on Mancini’s team selection, particularly the decision to start an untested front three of Esposito, Luca Koleosho and central midfielder Niccolo Pisilli, who was playing out of position.
The newspaper said Italy had produced an encouraging opening 10 minutes, capped by Esposito’s 10th Azzurri goal, but then appeared to stop playing. It added that Belgium could have scored twice as many goals on another night.
Even so, La Gazzetta dello Sport considered it preferable for such a performance to happen at this stage rather than later in the team’s development.
The Corriere dello Sport also believed Italy were fortunate not to concede more, with Gianluigi Donnarumma’s display in goal helping to limit the damage. It described the first-half collapse as particularly disappointing after the work Italy had put into their earlier Nations League matches.
Pisilli and Nicolo Fagioli were criticised individually after both were substituted at half-time, while Esposito was praised for reaching 10 goals in his first 15 international appearances.
The Corriere dello Sport also called for patience, arguing: “You can’t ask youngsters to learn and grow and then demolish them for their mistakes, we must support them.”
Tuttosport took a more positive view of Italy’s overall campaign, saying there were still plenty of encouraging signs and that the Azzurri had “come a long way” since their first meeting with Belgium in September.
It noted that Italy collected 10 points from a group containing France, Belgium and Turkey, all of whom qualified for the 2026 World Cup that the Azzurri infamously missed.
Mancini was credited with returning Italy to modern European standards through a 4-3-3 formation, trusting younger players and bringing the best out of Esposito as a centre-forward.
However, Tuttosport identified Italy’s defence as the main concern. They failed to keep a clean sheet in any of their six Nations League group matches and conceded twice against Turkey, who ended the group stage with six consecutive defeats.
The newspaper urged Italy to focus on the future, particularly the Euro 2028 qualifiers, which it regards as more important than the Nations League campaign.