Gary Neville has defended Diogo Dalot and urged Manchester United to consider selling Noussair Mazraoui, Lisandro Martinez and Matthijs de Ligt before deciding on the Portuguese right-back’s future.
Dalot has faced strong criticism during a difficult season for both the player and Manchester United’s defence. However, the former United defender believes Dalot has become an easy target, partly because he is not receiving enough support from those around him.
Neville also warned incoming manager Mauricio Pochettino against making a rushed decision over Dalot, arguing that the full-back’s performances should be assessed alongside the wider defensive structure.
“I think if he was playing in a good back four, he would be in a better position,” Neville said while speaking to Mark Goldbridge on the Sticking to United programme.
“But his back four is a disaster. His position is not ideal, and he can improve with the ball and in everything he does, but I think he has become far too easy a target for criticism.”
Neville, as reported by the Daily Mail, said he sometimes heard United-supporting friends mocking Dalot and wondered whether they were seeing something he was missing.
However, he said he would begin a defensive rebuild by moving on from Mazraoui, Martinez and de Ligt before considering Dalot’s departure from Old Trafford.
“I would get rid of Mazraoui long before Dalot, and Martinez as well. De Ligt too,” Neville added.
“He has a big problem because he does not play football. If a player is injury-prone and does not play regularly, you cannot favour him over a player who plays every week. You want someone you can rely on and who is available consistently.”
Neville said Martinez would be among his departures without hesitation, while de Ligt’s repeated injury problems also made him a candidate to leave during the proposed changes.
He expects Pochettino to retain Dalot, Luke Shaw, Harry Maguire and Leny Yoro, although he believes Manchester United may still need to sign a new left-back because of Shaw’s injury record.
“He will keep Shaw because he knows him well and may be able to get the best out of him,” Neville said. “But his problem is injuries, so he will have to manage him carefully, and he will also need to sign a left-back.”
Neville also backed Maguire to stay, suggesting Pochettino could trust him to carry out the defensive duties required.
He believes Yoro has significant potential despite weaknesses in his current performances. Neville described the France defender as looking thin and lacking physical balance in some situations, comparing his movement to “Bambi on ice”, but said he could improve as he gained strength and experience.
Yoro’s call-up to the France squad, Neville added, showed the ability he possesses, even if he had not yet displayed it consistently at Manchester United. He pointed to Rio Ferdinand’s physical development after joining United, noting that Sir Alex Ferguson had also identified Ferdinand’s need to become stronger.
Neville concluded that Pochettino would need to sign at least three new defenders, while retaining Shaw, Maguire, Yoro and Dalot and releasing Mazraoui, de Ligt and Martinez.
His view on Martinez comes as the Argentina defender continues to play for Manchester United this season, despite criticising the club’s management in an interview last month. That has made him a prominent name in discussions surrounding the future of United’s defence.