New Zealand have faced widespread criticism after England inflicted a record 37-12 defeat on the All Blacks at Twickenham on Saturday.
The 25-point loss was New Zealand’s heaviest against England and came only a week after their shock 35-28 defeat by Wales, their first loss to the Welsh in 73 years.
The result dropped Dave Rennie’s side to fifth in the World Rugby rankings and intensified concerns about their direction with the 2027 Rugby World Cup in Australia now less than a year away.
Media coverage in New Zealand and overseas questioned whether the All Blacks’ long-established aura had disappeared, with several reports highlighting how little threat they posed during England’s dominant performance.
The Guardian praised England’s display as one of “remarkable quality”, saying New Zealand were unable to match their opponents. It pointed to England’s 19-0 advantage after 36 minutes and Ollie Chessum’s try soon after half-time, which left the visitors facing an almost impossible recovery.
The newspaper added that the result could damage New Zealand’s reputation as heavily as the previous week’s defeat by Wales.
The Independent said the response expected after the loss in Cardiff had failed to appear. It described the All Blacks as “shut down, shut out and shut up” while England controlled the match, and suggested the victory could move England into the discussion as genuine contenders for the 2027 Rugby World Cup.
The Telegraph focused on what it called the fading mystique of New Zealand rugby. It questioned whether the All Blacks’ historic reputation still carried the same authority, citing three successive defeats by South Africa this year, the loss to Wales and the heavy defeat at Twickenham.
It also questioned the impact Rennie has made since replacing Scott Robertson, who was dismissed earlier this year.
New Zealand outlet Stuff said the defeat would leave the leadership of New Zealand Rugby facing difficult questions. It was the team’s fifth Test defeat of the 2026 season and dealt another blow to their hopes of reaching the Nations Championship final, with South Africa moving above them after earning a bonus point in their defeat by Ireland.
Planet Rugby described the 37-12 display as “abject”, criticising the All Blacks’ decision-making, execution, physicality, defence and attack. It questioned what the team currently offers beyond its scrum, goalkicking and the traditional pre-match haka.
The Post called the result a complete humiliation and warned that New Zealand had significant work to do before next year’s World Cup. The BBC likewise reported that the All Blacks had been reduced to a minor role at Twickenham, while offering context for their struggles.
New Zealand have played nine Tests in less than three months since July’s Nations Championship, including four matches in South Africa and the extra travel involved in the Greatest Rivalry series in Baltimore. Injuries to Ruben Love, Quinn Tupaea, Caleb Clarke and Leroy Carter have also weakened the backline.
Rennie’s team will have an immediate chance to respond when they meet England again at Twickenham on Saturday, 28 November, in the Nations Championship third-place playoff.