Gary Neville says Manchester City’s guilty verdict risks causing lasting damage to the Premier League’s reputation around the world, warning that the competition could suffer a decline similar to Serie A after Italy’s Calciopoli scandal.
An independent commission found City guilty on almost all charges this week, with the case involving alleged sham deals worth £900m. The verdict, which revealed the extraordinary scale of the club’s alleged cheating, has sent shockwaves through football and wider society.
City remain determined to appeal, while sanctions have yet to be announced. Neville believes the continuing legal process could overshadow this season as well as the previous decade, prolonging the damage to the Premier League’s image.
Speaking on the latest Stick to Football podcast, former Manchester United defender Neville said: “I’m chilled, this is chilling not celebratory. I support Manchester United, you support Liverpool, you were Arsenal. It is chilling to listen to this.”
He compared the situation with the impact of Calciopoli, the 2006 scandal which exposed how Italian clubs influenced referees. Juventus were stripped of titles and relegated to Serie B as a result.
“The Italian game has suffered immeasurably in the last 25 years,” Neville said. “We played against Juventus, we’ve alluded to this before, we felt at the time this wasn’t right and the Italian… I’m not saying that’s going to happen to the Premier League but we always think that we’ve got an enormous integrity, the Premier League, that we are the sort of league that sets the standard and it’s other leagues that have got corruption, fraud, doping scandals, match fixing, referee scandals.
“This is now coming to our country, this is now coming to our league. This is the greatest export that we have in our country in the world.”
Neville added: “If you go around the world and talk about Liverpool, Manchester United, Arsenal, you talk about the Premier League.
“People talk about the Premier League more than anything when you tell them where you’re from. At the moment, we’re being dragged through the mud.”
Political row over Manchester City owners
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has been criticised for a “tone deaf” response to the verdict, after expressing concern about the possibility of Manchester City losing their Abu Dhabi owners.
Speaking at Everton’s Hill Dickinson Stadium, Burnham said: “I would be really concerned to lose (Man City’s Abu Dhabi owners).
“They’ve been such a huge partner in the building of modern Manchester and obviously the building of Manchester City into the global force that it is.”
Burnham said it would be wrong for him to intervene or reach a conclusion before studying the detail, adding that Manchester City were still contesting the verdict.
Stan Collymore described the comments as “tone deaf” and “clunky”, citing them as an example of the power of sports-washing. Rio Ferdinand said Burnham appeared to be “on the back foot referencing Manchester City”.
Other commenters called the statement “political interference” and said it suggested clubs could “cheat the system” if they paid enough. The dispute reaching the highest levels of politics underlines the scale of the biggest cheating scandal in British sporting history and the potential consequences for the Premier League.