New Zealand’s rugby crisis intensified as the All Blacks were beaten 37-12 by England at Twickenham, their heaviest-ever Test defeat by their opponents.
The 25-point loss came only seven days after New Zealand were stunned 35-28 by Wales, their first defeat by the Welsh in 73 years. The back-to-back setbacks have placed renewed scrutiny on head coach Dave Rennie and the direction of the team.
Rennie recalled several experienced players for the meeting with England, but the changes failed to produce the reaction New Zealand needed. England controlled much of the contest and crossed the line five times through Henry Slade, Jack van Poortvliet, Ben Earl, Ollie Chessum and Seb Atkinson.
The All Blacks scored twice, through Ethan de Groot and Beauden Barrett, but were unable to prevent England from recording a landmark victory.
Rennie accepted that the performance fell well short of expectations and said he shared responsibility for the result.
“As a coach you’re responsible for the results,” he said.
“I’m not going to hide that we weren’t good enough and I’m a part of that. We were miles off and this is not where we want to be.”
The New Zealand coach also acknowledged that the display was worse than the defeat by Wales the previous week.
New Zealand have now lost five of their 12 Tests under Rennie, matching their worst losing sequence in the professional era. Rennie’s record stands at seven victories from those 12 matches, giving him a win percentage of 58.3%.
That record compares with Rassie Erasmus’ 73.8% winning rate as head coach of the Springboks. Against the All Blacks, Erasmus has overseen 12 matches, winning seven, losing four and drawing one, a win percentage of 58.3%.
Although Erasmus is not expected to take charge of New Zealand, the contrast highlights the scale of the challenge facing the All Blacks. The South Africa coach has developed a squad renowned for its depth, clear identity and ability to adjust to different opponents and situations.
England’s success was also significant for Steve Borthwick’s side. They have beaten New Zealand in consecutive Tests for the first time since 2002 and 2003, following a 33-19 victory at Twickenham in 2025. The result extended England’s winning run to five Tests after a disappointing Six Nations campaign.
Former England captain Lewis Moody joined his country’s V-formation response to the All Blacks haka before kick-off. Moody was diagnosed with motor neurone disease last year. England captain Maro Itoje said his presence was inspirational and gave the team an extra lift.
England will meet New Zealand again at Twickenham on Saturday, 28 November, in the third-place play-off of the Nations Championship.
England missed the final after France beat Argentina 45-17. France will face the Springboks in the final, while Rennie must find solutions to the problems exposed by New Zealand’s successive defeats.