Gary Neville condemns ‘awful’ Manchester United defending after Matthijs de Ligt selection

Manchester United were reduced to 10 men after only 8 minutes against Liverpool, with Matthijs De Ligt and Leny Yoro making successive defensive errors in an incident that prompted strong criticism from former United defender Gary Neville.

Araujo’s long pass appeared straightforward for De Ligt to clear, but the defender failed to control the situation and allowed the ball to run beyond him. Isak immediately broke through, with Yoro attempting to recover.

Isak reached the ball 1st and was fouled by Yoro, who was shown a red card by referee Sam Barrott. United were therefore forced to play most of the match with 10 men.

Speaking on Sky Sports, Neville questioned the decision to start De Ligt and criticised the positioning of both centre-backs.

“When I saw De Ligt’s name in the starting lineup, I have to admit I was completely stunned. I was shocked because, if you’d seen him play for Como 4 weeks ago, you’d know he was in poor form. And this was just a very basic long pass.”

Neville said the mistake began with De Ligt, but added that Yoro’s response had also been inadequate.

“First of all, it was De Ligt’s fault. Yoro could have been positioned wider, but De Ligt was too far from the ball. Yoro then had to take a much wider route to get back. His reaction was too slow, and his anticipation was terrible. Yoro looked very clumsy, and he has made many similar mistakes.”

He rejected the suggestion that Isak had deliberately slowed down to draw the foul.

“You could argue that Isak deliberately slowed down to make Yoro run into him, but that’s a naive argument.”

United manager Carrick had to reorganise his defence after Yoro’s dismissal. However, before he could introduce Maguire, Wirtz had made it 2-0 to Liverpool. Maguire eventually came on as a substitute, although the change appeared to have come too late.

Neville later returned to De Ligt’s display, acknowledging his lengthy absence but saying the match had exposed his weaknesses.

“We saw him at Como, and he’d been out for a year. It’s difficult to come back from injury, but putting him in a game like this exposed his weaknesses. Yoro’s positioning was also very poor; he needed to be wider. You have to protect your partner. Man United’s overall performance was very poor.”

He added that Carrick would view the match as evidence of the scale of the task ahead, saying: “This is what I have to deal with.”

After reviewing the incident again, Neville delivered an even harsher verdict.

“This is the worst defensive display you’ll ever see from 2 centre-backs dealing with a long ball. De Ligt was completely disconnected. He’s been out for a long time, and I have some sympathy for that. But for both of them to let the ball go between them is unforgivable.”

“It’s shocking. As long as Man United have defenders like these, they won’t keep a clean sheet.”

“This comes down to a basic understanding of their positions and the most fundamental defensive skills. It looks as though these players have never received basic defensive training.”

Former Manchester United captain Roy Keane also criticised the defending at half-time.

“Whether you play with a back 4 or a back 5, you have to get the basics right.”

“At this level, I’m shocked by it. I know he’s been out for a while, but that defending was awful. There was no way he was going to get to that ball.”

“As a defender, you have to be prepared for the worst-case scenario at all times. Isak dealt with it well, but honestly, I didn’t think he would get to that ball either.”

“Yoro had no chance of getting to the ball. Man United’s defending was so clumsy. All Liverpool needed was a through ball in behind, and United would have been in huge trouble. I know Yoro is fast and agile, but that defending was just terrible. The players simply didn’t realize the danger was coming.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Read More