Thomas Tuchel’s decision to leave Jordan Pickford out of England’s starting XI and select James Trafford against Spain has reignited the contest to become the team’s number one goalkeeper.
Tuchel had confirmed Trafford’s selection before the match, saying: “James Trafford will be in goal. We will give him this opportunity, trust him, and see how he performs in a high-pressure match.”
The game was Trafford’s fifth senior appearance for England, and he justified the manager’s decision with a series of outstanding saves. The goalkeeper, who became England’s most expensive in his position when Leeds United paid Manchester City 52.5 million euros for him this summer, could not prevent Mikel Oyarzabal’s penalty or Nico Williams’ goal.
However, after England went 3-0 up, Trafford produced six saves, including five of considerable difficulty, to ensure his side did not leave empty-handed.
He denied Fermin from close range in the 72nd minute before blocking Lamine Yamal’s effort towards the far corner eight minutes later. Trafford then recovered to keep out Marc Cucurella’s follow-up on the line after the shot had taken a dangerous deflection off Ben White.
The goalkeeper saved his best sequence until stoppage time. In the 91st minute, he first stopped another effort from Fermin after the forward had turned, then reacted sharply to scoop up Aymeric Laporte’s rebound from the base of the post before parrying a second attempt.
“Everything happened very quickly, but this is what we train for every day: to make decisions in a fraction of a second,” Trafford said. “I am very happy to help the team. It was a wonderful moment. In terms of the importance of these saves, I would say they were among my best. I am happy with the win and happy to have contributed, helping the team qualify as group winners.”
Spain manager Luis de la Fuente acknowledged Trafford’s influence, saying: “We created several chances, but the England goalkeeper had a great performance: he saved two or three goals in the last 10 to 15 minutes.”
It was another impressive performance against Spain from Trafford. In 2023, he denied Santi Denia’s side victory in the U21 European Championship after saving Abel Ruiz’s penalty in the 99th minute and then stopping Oroz’s rebound.
Tuchel said England still had no established first-choice goalkeeper. “There is no clear number one goalkeeper yet,” he said. “That double save was excellent, truly excellent. That’s exactly what we want. He played a great game.”
Declan Rice added: “Everything happened so fast, in just a fraction of a second. He made two saves in just two seconds, which is impressive. It was an incredible night for him.”
Former Arsenal defender Lee Dixon described the stops as “world-class saves”, while The Telegraph said it was “only a matter of time before James Trafford becomes England’s undisputed number one goalkeeper”. The Guardian wrote that “James Trafford’s dream is still alive: the number one goalkeeper position is once again open.”
Trafford’s route back to the England team
Trafford came through the Manchester City academy and gained experience on loan at Accrington Stanley during the 2021-22 season and Bolton in 2022-23.
After starring in the 2023 U21 European Championship final, he joined Burnley for 17 million euros. He spent two seasons at Turf Moor, during which the club were relegated to the Championship and then returned to the Premier League.
That form led Manchester City to bring him back a year later for 31.2 million euros. Trafford made 17 appearances under Pep Guardiola, conceding 13 goals and recording eight clean sheets.
“This is not how I envisioned the start of the season, but this is where I am now, and I have to give my best,” he said after a League Cup match.
But after growing tired of living in Gianluigi Donnarumma’s “shadow”, Trafford moved to Leeds United. Following his display against Spain, England’s goalkeeper debate is firmly open.